NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway

Reviewed · NYC BROADWAY SHOWS

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway

Operated by Broadway Inbound · Bookable on GetYourGuide
Book on GetYourGuide →

This Broadway night runs on laughs and movement. The Book of Mormon mixes old-Broadway big song-and-dance energy with a modern edge, following two missionaries in Uganda as the comedy aims its spotlight at religion, sexuality, poverty, and race. I especially like the fact that the show won 8 Tony Awards, including Best Musical, so you’re not just buying a ticket, you’re buying a proven hit.

I also like how the humor comes straight from the comedy playbook of Trey Parker and Matt Stone of South Park, with Robert Lopez (from Avenue Q) helping shape the mix. One key consideration: the show uses explicit language, so it’s not a safe pick for younger kids, even if it looks like a fun evening on paper.

Key reasons to see The Book of Mormon on Broadway

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - Key reasons to see The Book of Mormon on Broadway

  • 8 Tony Awards (Best Musical too): A serious awards record behind an otherwise silly premise
  • South Park-level shock humor: Parker and Stone’s style keeps the jokes moving fast
  • Big classic Broadway numbers: Old-school musical theater format with modern bite
  • A story with built-in tension: Elder Price and Elder Cunningham clash in all the right ways
  • You’re part of the energy: The show is designed for laughs and dancing in your seat

Curtain up: more Broadway seats

The Book of Mormon’s Broadway style: big numbers, modern punch

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - The Book of Mormon’s Broadway style: big numbers, modern punch
If you want a Broadway show that feels like the genre’s old-school muscle—big songs, big choreography, big stage confidence—this one delivers. The format is built around old-Broadway-style storytelling, where the music and movement help land the laughs even when the subject matter gets uncomfortable.

What makes it interesting is the modern sensibility on top of that classic stage machinery. The story follows two young missionaries sent to Uganda to convert citizens, and the comedy uses their good intentions as the engine. Elder Price is the enthusiastic overachiever with strong faith, while Elder Cunningham is well-meaning but socially unfit. That contrast creates the constant problem: they think they’re prepared, and the world keeps proving otherwise.

The result is a show that laughs at big topics—religion, sexuality, poverty, and race—without slowing down. You get jokes, yes, but you also get that theater rhythm where each scene builds to the next musical beat. It’s the kind of show that keeps you switched on, because the writing doesn’t hover; it pushes.

Eugene O’Neill Theatre: where your night starts

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - Eugene O’Neill Theatre: where your night starts
Your ticket needs to be presented at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre. That’s the key practical detail to lock in so your evening stays smooth. Since the show includes your entry ticket only, this is also a good moment to think about your pre-show plan: eat ahead of time, and treat any food or drinks sold at the venue as extra.

I like that the meeting point is straightforward. When you’re in Midtown for a Broadway night, confusion is common; having a single clear theater location makes a real difference. You can focus on the fun part—getting settled and ready for a comedy that moves fast.

Following Elder Price and Elder Cunningham in Uganda

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - Following Elder Price and Elder Cunningham in Uganda
The plot is simple enough to follow, but it’s designed to keep surprising you. Two young missionaries arrive on a mission, confident they can do the job. Then the show starts poking at what happens when a faith-based script meets a reality shaped by poverty and violence.

Elder Price and Elder Cunningham don’t just walk through scenes; they create the comedy through their mismatch. Elder Price is portrayed as driven and earnest—someone who treats the mission like a personal achievement project. Elder Cunningham is the partner who wants to do right, but keeps getting tangled in social misfires. The humor comes from that gap between intent and outcome, with musical set pieces turning awkward moments into full Broadway spectacle.

If you like character-driven comedy—where the jokes come from personality collisions—this show has a lot to offer. It’s not one long stand-up routine. It’s more like watching two very mismatched people try to stay on script while the world keeps throwing curveballs.

Same slot on the itinerary, a different New York City idea

What the show is actually laughing at (and why that matters)

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - What the show is actually laughing at (and why that matters)
The show’s comedic target is clear: it’s an atheist-minded look at the Mormon religion, with broad humor aimed at religion itself. It also digs into sexuality, poverty, and race, and it does so with a deliberately irreverent tone.

This is where you should decide if you’re in the right mood. If you’re comfortable with edgy satire and explicit language, you’ll probably find the jokes land hard and fast. If you prefer comedy that stays safely distant from real-world issues, you might find parts of the material heavy or too blunt.

The good news is that the show’s structure helps. The big song-and-dance numbers act like a release valve: the comedy is sharp, but the musical format keeps pulling you along. You’re less likely to feel stuck in any one uncomfortable moment because the show keeps cycling through jokes, performances, and new situations.

The creators behind the punchlines: Parker, Stone, and Lopez

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - The creators behind the punchlines: Parker, Stone, and Lopez
One of the best reasons to pick this show is the team shaping the humor. Trey Parker and Matt Stone (the South Park creators) are involved, and Robert Lopez (who worked on Avenue Q) is also part of the creative force.

That combo tells you what kind of evening you’re buying. South Park fans will recognize the attitude: quick jokes, blunt satire, and a willingness to be politically incorrect on purpose. Avenue Q fans will recognize the musical-theater know-how: clever songcraft paired with laughs that sometimes have teeth.

I like that the show doesn’t feel like it’s imitating Broadway—it uses Broadway tools to deliver a very non-Broadway style of comedy. The result is a hybrid that works: old-school showmanship paired with jokes you don’t usually hear in a traditional musical.

Planning your Broadway evening: tickets, food, and a smooth start

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - Planning your Broadway evening: tickets, food, and a smooth start
This experience includes entry ticket only. Food and drinks aren’t included, though they are available for purchase. That matters because it affects your budget and pacing. If you go in hungry, you’ll be tempted to buy concessions during the evening, and a comedy show like this is better when you’re not distracted by logistics.

Also, reserve tickets early. This isn’t just marketing fluff—it’s practical advice for getting the experience you want in New York City. A popular Broadway title tends to sell well, and early reservations give you more flexibility.

Here’s a simple strategy I’d use for a stress-free night: eat before you arrive, plan for drinks to be extra, and focus on getting to the Eugene O’Neill Theatre with time to settle. Once you’re seated, you can let the show do what it does best: make you laugh and move.

Value check: does The Book of Mormon fit your kind of fun?

You’re paying for a Broadway comedy that’s already proven to work. The show has a winner’s track record—8 Tony Awards including Best Musical—and that raises the odds you’ll get a tightly produced performance rather than a risky novelty.

The other value is clarity. The show description tells you what it is: a blockbuster musical with big songs, modern sensibility, and irreverent humor around religion and social themes. No guesswork about whether it will be too serious or too light; it’s aiming for laughs, dance energy, and satire.

The main trade-off is the content. The explicit language makes this a teens and up recommendation, and the show is not positioned as family-friendly. If you’re bringing a group, be sure everyone is on the same page about humor style and language.

Who it’s for

  • Adults and older teens who like satire and musical comedy
  • People who want a full Broadway night: songs, dancing, and momentum
  • Anyone curious about how Parker and Stone’s brand of humor translates into musical theater

Who should skip it

  • Families with younger kids who need clean comedy
  • Anyone who dislikes jokes about religion, sexuality, poverty, or race

Should you book The Book of Mormon on Broadway?

If you want a guaranteed, high-energy Broadway comedy and you’re comfortable with explicit language, I think it’s an easy yes. The combination of classic Broadway staging, modern joke-writing, and a record like Best Musical at the Tony Awards makes this a strong value for an evening in NYC.

If you’re unsure about the humor style, treat the explicit language warning as your deciding signal. For the right audience, it’s a fun night that uses theater at full volume. For everyone else, it can feel too blunt for comfort.

FAQ

NYC: The Book of Mormon the Musical on Broadway - FAQ

Where do I present my ticket for The Book of Mormon?

Present your ticket at the Eugene O’Neill Theatre.

What’s included with this experience?

The entry ticket is included.

Are food and drinks included?

No. Food and drinks are available for purchase.

Who created the musical?

Trey Parker and Matt Stone (South Park creators) and Robert Lopez (from Avenue Q) are involved.

What is the basic storyline of the musical?

Two young missionaries are sent to Uganda to try to convert citizens.

Which characters does the show focus on?

Elder Price and Elder Cunningham.

What kind of musical style should I expect?

Old-Broadway-style big song-and-dance numbers with a modern sensibility.

Is the show appropriate for younger children?

The show contains explicit language and is recommended for teens and up.

How many Tony Awards has The Book of Mormon won?

It has won 8 Tony Awards, including Best Musical.